Browse suburbsGuidesHow we rankGet started →
Home>How We Rank

How We Rank Childcare Centres in Melbourne

Our methodology is transparent, independent and consistent across every suburb. No centre can pay to appear in our rankings or improve their position.

Our independence pledge

top3elc.com.au does not accept payment, sponsorship, or any form of compensation from childcare centres, operators, or affiliated businesses to appear in our rankings, receive a higher position, or be featured more prominently.

Every ranking is determined by the same criteria applied consistently across all suburbs. Centres cannot influence their position through any commercial arrangement.

TL;DR: How We Rank

Last updated: August 2026

We weigh five things together: NQS rating and how recent it is, what parents say, program and environment, fees and what they include, and practical fit. NQS carries the most weight where centres sit at clearly different levels; where they're close, the other four decide the order. We don't accept payment from centres, and we don't rank by who owns a centre.

How we rank

We start by identifying the long day care centres in a suburb from the ACECQA register via Starting Blocks, then assess the candidates against five things we weigh together.

We deliberately do not publish a scoring formula or individual weightings. This is to prevent gaming; we want centres focused on genuinely improving quality for children and families, not optimising for a score. we make a judgement call for each suburb based on the totality of the evidence available.

01

🏅 NQS rating and how recent it is

A rating is a snapshot of one assessment visit, so we look at both the level and the date. A rating from 2019 tells you less about a centre today than one from 2026.

NQS rating levels
Exceeding NQSDemonstrates practice that goes beyond the requirements of the NQS across all quality areas. The gold standard.
Meeting NQSMeets all quality standards across every area of the National Quality Framework. A strong, reliable rating.
Working TowardsWorking towards the standard in one or more quality areas. Does not necessarily indicate poor quality. May reflect a new assessment cycle.
ProvisionalStandard for newly approved services that have not yet undergone their first assessment. Not a quality judgement.
02

💬 What parents say

Reviews across Google and other platforms, weighted for volume and consistency rather than headline score. A 5.0 from three reviews tells you less than a 4.6 from ninety.

03

📋 Program and environment

Educational philosophy, kinder integration, the physical spaces, and what a centre actually offers beyond care.

04

💰 Fees and what they include

The daily rate, and whether meals, nappies and incursions are covered or charged on top.

05

🕐 Practical fit

Hours, ages served, capacity, CCS approval and Free Kinder access.

NQS carries the most weight where centres sit at clearly different levels. Where they're close, or where an assessment is several years old, the other four decide the order. We will rank a Meeting centre above an Exceeding one where the evidence supports it, and we'll say why on the page.

We don't rank by who owns a centre. Private operators, not-for-profits and large groups are assessed the same way.

Our data sources

Every data point on top3elc.com.au is sourced from a verifiable, public source. We do not use proprietary data or make claims we cannot substantiate.

NQS ratings, assessment dates, service approval status, fees, vacancies, service type, capacity

Google Reviews

Parent ratings and review volume, the largest single source of parent feedback for most centres

Centre websites

Program details, educator profiles, fee schedules, enrolment information, philosophy statements

Our research process

1
Identify all centres

We start by identifying every long day care centre in the suburb using the ACECQA register via Starting Blocks.

2
Gather data

For each centre, we collect NQS ratings, fees, parent reviews from all platforms, program details, and practical information.

3
Assess and rank

We weigh the five factors together to determine the top 3. In suburbs with fewer than 3 long day care centres, we rank only those available.

4
Write review

Each suburb guide includes verified data, attributed parent quotes, our independent take, and practical information like phone numbers and directions.

5
Verify and publish

All data is verified before publication. Fees are confirmed against Starting Blocks. NQS ratings are confirmed against ACECQA. Guides note the date of last update.

6
Monitor and update

We monitor for NQS re-assessments, fee changes, and new parent reviews. Guides are updated when material changes occur.

Common questions about our methodology

Can a centre pay to be ranked higher?

No. We do not accept payment, sponsorship, or any form of compensation from centres. Rankings are determined entirely by our published criteria.

How much weight does the NQS rating carry?

NQS carries the most weight where centres sit at clearly different levels. A rating is a snapshot of one assessment visit, so we weigh both the level and the date. Where ratings are close, or where an assessment is several years old, the other four factors decide the order. We will rank a Meeting centre above an Exceeding one where the evidence supports it, and we say why on the page.

What about centres that are new and don't have an NQS rating yet?

New services receive a Provisional classification until their first formal assessment. We can still rank these centres based on parent reviews, operator track record, program quality, and fee transparency. We clearly disclose the Provisional status in our review.

How often do you update rankings?

Suburb guides are reviewed whenever material changes occur, such as a new NQS assessment, significant fee changes, or notable shifts in parent reviews. Each guide displays its last updated date.

Why only top 3?

Three is enough to give families a meaningful shortlist without overwhelming them. Our goal is to narrow the field, not list every option. We recommend families tour their top 2 to 3 choices in person before deciding.

Do you visit centres in person?

No. Our reviews are desk-based, drawing on publicly available data sources. The NQS assessment process involves physical site visits by independent assessors, and ratings are published on ACECQA's national register; we rely on those professional assessments as the primary quality indicator.

Ready to find the best childcare in your suburb?

Browse all suburbs →
Disclosure

top3elc.com.au is operated by the team behind Birches Early Learning. Birches centres are assessed on the same five factors as every other centre on this site, and their position reflects that assessment. Centres cannot pay to appear, rank higher, or receive preferred placement.

Every other centre ranked on this site has no commercial relationship with us. We do not accept payment from any centre to influence rankings, and we never have.